docs: add comprehensive implementation plan with timeline and budget

2026-01-12 13:08:59 +00:00
parent 97699c22a4
commit 9ea4c693f6
1 changed files with 838 additions and 0 deletions
--- a/docs/gitops-cicd/06-implementation-plan.md
+++ b/docs/gitops-cicd/06-implementation-plan.md
@@ -0,0 +1,838 @@
+# FinTech GitOps CI/CD - План внедрения
+
+**Версия:** 1.0  
+**Дата:** Январь 2026  
+**Целевая аудитория:** Management, Project Managers, All Teams
+
+---
+
+## Содержание
+
+1. [Executive Summary](#1-executive-summary)
+2. [Timeline Overview](#2-timeline-overview)
+3. [Detailed Implementation Plan](#3-detailed-implementation-plan)
+4. [Risks and Mitigation](#4-risks-and-mitigation)
+5. [Resource Requirements](#5-resource-requirements)
+6. [Budget and ROI](#6-budget-and-roi)
+7. [Success Metrics](#7-success-metrics)
+8. [Communication Plan](#8-communication-plan)
+
+---
+
+## 1. Executive Summary
+
+### 1.1 Project Overview
+
+**Цель:** Внедрение современной CI/CD методологии на базе GitOps принципов для автоматизации разработки, тестирования и развертывания приложений в закрытой инфраструктуре FinTech компании.
+
+**Scope:**
+- Полная инфраструктура CI/CD с GitOps automation
+- Development и Production окружения
+- AI-ассистент для технической поддержки
+- Обучение всех команд
+- Миграция существующих приложений
+
+**Duration:** 6 месяцев (Development environment: 5 недель, Production: 4 месяца, Migration: продолжается)
+
+**Budget:** $150,000 - $230,000 (hardware) + $20,000/year (software licenses) + внутренние ресурсы
+
+### 1.2 Expected Benefits
+
+**Количественные:**
+- Deployment frequency: с 1-2/месяц до 10+/день
+- Lead time: с 2-4 недель до <4 часов
+- MTTR: с 2-4 часов до <15 минут
+- Change failure rate: с 20-30% до <5%
+
+**Качественные:**
+- Полный audit trail для compliance
+- Снижение operational risks
+- Faster time to market
+- Improved team satisfaction
+- Better resource utilization
+
+**Финансовые:**
+- ROI: 12-18 месяцев
+- Экономия на downtime: ~$200k/year
+- Экономия времени команд: 40% → ~$150k/year
+- **Total annual benefit: ~$350k/year**
+
+---
+
+## 2. Timeline Overview
+
+### 2.1 High-Level Phases
+
+```
+Month 1-2: Planning & Development Environment
+├── Week 1-2: Planning, approvals, procurement
+├── Week 3-5: Dev environment setup
+├── Week 6-8: Testing, validation, training
+
+Month 3-4: Production Infrastructure
+├── Week 9-10: Hardware procurement & delivery
+├── Week 11-14: Production setup
+├── Week 15-16: Testing & validation
+
+Month 5-6: Migration & Rollout
+├── Week 17-18: Pilot applications
+├── Week 19-22: Gradual migration
+├── Week 23-24: Stabilization & optimization
+
+Ongoing: Continuous Improvement
+```
+
+### 2.2 Critical Milestones
+
+| Milestone | Date | Deliverable |
+|-----------|------|-------------|
+| **M1: Project Kickoff** | Week 1 | Approved plan, team assigned |
+| **M2: Dev Environment Ready** | Week 5 | Fully functional dev environment |
+| **M3: Team Trained** | Week 8 | Team comfortable with tools |
+| **M4: Hardware Delivered** | Week 10 | All production hardware on-site |
+| **M5: Production Ready** | Week 16 | Production environment operational |
+| **M6: First Pilot Success** | Week 18 | 2 apps successfully migrated |
+| **M7: 50% Migration** | Week 22 | Half of apps using GitOps |
+| **M8: Project Complete** | Week 24 | All critical apps migrated |
+
+---
+
+## 3. Detailed Implementation Plan
+
+### Month 1: Planning & Initial Setup
+
+#### Week 1-2: Project Initiation
+
+**Activities:**
+- Finalize project plan и получить approvals
+- Form project team и assign roles
+- Conduct stakeholder kickoff meeting
+- Submit hardware procurement requests
+- Setup project management tracking (Jira/Confluence)
+
+**Team:**
+- Project Manager (1 FTE)
+- DevOps Engineers (2 FTE)
+- Infrastructure Engineers (1 FTE)
+- Security Architect (0.5 FTE)
+- Network Engineer (0.5 FTE)
+
+**Deliverables:**
+- Approved project plan
+- Team roster и RACI matrix
+- Procurement orders submitted
+- Project tracking setup
+- Communication channels established
+
+**Approvals Required:**
+- Budget approval (Finance)
+- Security review (CISO)
+- Compliance sign-off (Compliance Officer)
+- Network changes (Network team)
+
+#### Week 3-5: Development Environment Setup
+
+**Week 3: Base Infrastructure**
+- Network setup (VLANs, firewall rules)
+- Server provisioning (12 VMs)
+- OS installation и basic hardening
+- Storage configuration
+
+**Week 4: Core Services**
+- Gitea deployment и configuration
+- Jenkins setup с essential plugins
+- Harbor installation
+- PostgreSQL databases
+- Initial testing
+
+**Week 5: Orchestration & AI**
+- Docker Swarm initialization
+- Portainer deployment
+- GitOps Operator setup
+- Ollama & MCP Server deployment
+- End-to-end integration testing
+
+**Deliverables:**
+- Fully functional dev environment
+- All services operational
+- Integration tests passed
+- Initial documentation
+
+### Month 2: Testing & Training
+
+#### Week 6-7: Comprehensive Testing
+
+**Functional Testing:**
+- CI/CD pipeline testing (multiple application types)
+- GitOps workflow validation
+- Rollback procedures
+- Security scanning
+
+**Performance Testing:**
+- Load testing Jenkins builds
+- High-frequency deployments
+- Monitoring under load
+
+**Security Testing:**
+- Vulnerability scanning
+- Penetration testing basics
+- Access control verification
+- Audit logging validation
+
+**Disaster Recovery:**
+- Backup/restore procedures
+- Failover testing
+- Data recovery scenarios
+
+**Deliverables:**
+- Test reports
+- Identified issues и resolutions
+- Performance baselines
+- Updated documentation
+
+#### Week 8: Team Training
+
+**Training Modules:**
+
+**Day 1-2: GitOps Fundamentals**
+- GitOps concepts и principles
+- Infrastructure as Code
+- Git workflows (branching, PR, merge)
+- Hands-on: Create repository, make changes
+
+**Day 3-4: CI/CD Pipelines**
+- Jenkins overview
+- Pipeline as Code (Jenkinsfile)
+- Docker image builds
+- Security scanning integration
+- Hands-on: Build first pipeline
+
+**Day 5-6: Docker Swarm & Deployment**
+- Docker Swarm concepts
+- Service deployment
+- Scaling и rolling updates
+- Troubleshooting
+- Hands-on: Deploy application
+
+**Day 7: AI Assistant & Monitoring**
+- Using Ollama AI for support
+- Grafana dashboards
+- Log analysis via Loki
+- Alerting
+- Hands-on: Query AI, create dashboard
+
+**Day 8-9: Troubleshooting & Best Practices**
+- Common issues и solutions
+- Debugging techniques
+- Security best practices
+- Compliance requirements
+- Hands-on: Troubleshooting scenarios
+
+**Day 10: Assessment & Certification**
+- Practical assessment
+- Q&A session
+- Certification ceremony
+- Feedback collection
+
+**Participants:**
+- All DevOps team members (mandatory)
+- Development team leads (mandatory)
+- Interested developers (optional)
+- Operations team (mandatory)
+- Security team representatives
+
+**Deliverables:**
+- Training materials
+- Certification list
+- Feedback summary
+- Improvement recommendations
+
+### Month 3-4: Production Infrastructure
+
+#### Week 9-10: Hardware Procurement
+
+**Activities:**
+- Track hardware orders
+- Prepare datacenter space
+- Network cabling preparation
+- Power и cooling verification
+- Receive и inventory hardware
+
+**Parallel Activities:**
+- Refine production architecture based на dev learnings
+- Update documentation
+- Prepare production deployment scripts
+- Security review production design
+
+#### Week 11-14: Production Deployment
+
+**Week 11: Base Infrastructure**
+- Rack и stack hardware
+- BIOS configuration
+- Network configuration
+- Storage setup (RAID, LVM)
+- OS installation (all servers)
+- Basic hardening
+
+**Week 12: Core Services**
+- PostgreSQL cluster setup (master-slave)
+- Gitea production deployment
+- Jenkins production setup
+- Harbor production installation
+- Backup systems configuration
+
+**Week 13: Orchestration**
+- Docker Swarm production cluster (3 managers, 6+ workers)
+- Overlay networks
+- Secrets management
+- GitOps Operator deployment
+- Portainer production
+
+**Week 14: AI & Monitoring**
+- Ollama production (with GPU if available)
+- MCP Server production
+- Full monitoring stack (Prometheus, Grafana, Loki)
+- AlertManager configuration
+- Integration testing
+
+**Deliverables:**
+- Fully operational production environment
+- All HA configured
+- Backups operational
+- Monitoring active
+- Documentation updated
+
+#### Week 15-16: Production Validation
+
+**Testing:**
+- Comprehensive security audit
+- Penetration testing (external vendor)
+- Performance testing (производственная нагрузка)
+- Disaster recovery full drill
+- Compliance validation
+
+**Documentation:**
+- Production runbooks
+- Incident response procedures
+- Escalation matrix
+- SLA definitions
+- Maintenance windows
+
+**Final Approvals:**
+- Security sign-off
+- Compliance approval
+- Change Management Board approval
+- Executive sponsor sign-off
+
+**Deliverables:**
+- Security audit report
+- Penetration test results
+- Performance benchmarks
+- DR test results
+- Go-live approval
+
+### Month 5-6: Migration & Stabilization
+
+#### Week 17-18: Pilot Migration
+
+**Select Pilot Applications:**
+Criteria for pilot selection:
+- Non-critical to business (low risk)
+- Active development (frequent changes)
+- Team willing to be early adopters
+- Representative of typical applications
+
+**Pilot Applications (2-3):**
+1. Internal tool (low risk, high visibility)
+2. API service (moderate complexity)
+3. Web application (full stack)
+
+**Migration Process:**
+- Create Git repositories
+- Setup CI pipeline
+- Configure CD automation
+- Migrate deployment to Swarm
+- Monitor closely (1-2 weeks)
+
+**Success Criteria:**
+- Successful automated deployments
+- No major incidents
+- Improved deployment frequency
+- Positive team feedback
+- Performance maintained or improved
+
+**Deliverables:**
+- Pilot migration report
+- Lessons learned
+- Refined procedures
+- Updated training materials
+
+#### Week 19-22: Gradual Migration
+
+**Migration Schedule:**
+
+**Week 19:** Batch 1 (5 applications)
+- Low complexity applications
+- Well-documented
+- Active maintenance
+
+**Week 20:** Batch 2 (5 applications)
+- Medium complexity
+- Multiple teams
+- Integration points
+
+**Week 21:** Batch 3 (5 applications)
+- Higher complexity
+- Critical services (with extra caution)
+- Legacy code
+
+**Week 22:** Batch 4 (5 applications)
+- Most complex applications
+- High availability requirements
+- Compliance-sensitive
+
+**Migration Approach per Batch:**
+- Planning meeting (Monday)
+- Repository setup (Tuesday)
+- CI pipeline creation (Wednesday)
+- CD configuration (Thursday)
+- Migration execution (Friday)
+- Weekend: Close monitoring
+- Week after: Stabilization
+
+**Support:**
+- War room during migrations
+- 24/7 on-call during first weekend
+- Daily standup с pilot teams
+- Quick issue resolution
+
+#### Week 23-24: Stabilization
+
+**Activities:**
+- Monitor all migrated applications
+- Fine-tune resource allocations
+- Optimize CI/CD pipelines
+- Address technical debt
+- Improve documentation
+
+**Retrospective:**
+- Lessons learned workshop
+- Process improvements
+- Team feedback
+- Success celebration
+
+**Final Deliverables:**
+- Migration complete report
+- Updated documentation
+- Performance metrics
+- Cost savings analysis
+- Recommendations для future
+
+---
+
+## 4. Risks and Mitigation
+
+### 4.1 Technical Risks
+
+| Risk | Probability | Impact | Mitigation |
+|------|-------------|--------|------------|
+| **Hardware delivery delays** | Medium | High | Order early, have backup vendors |
+| **Integration issues** | Medium | Medium | Thorough testing в dev, phased rollout |
+| **Performance problems** | Low | Medium | Performance testing, capacity planning |
+| **Security vulnerabilities** | Low | Critical | Security review at each phase, pen testing |
+| **Data loss during migration** | Low | Critical | Multiple backups, tested restore procedures |
+| **Compatibility issues** | Medium | Medium | Dev environment mirrors production, thorough testing |
+
+### 4.2 Organizational Risks
+
+| Risk | Probability | Impact | Mitigation |
+|------|-------------|--------|------------|
+| **Resistance to change** | High | Medium | Clear communication, training, show benefits |
+| **Lack of skills** | Medium | High | Comprehensive training program, documentation |
+| **Key person dependency** | Medium | High | Knowledge sharing, documentation, cross-training |
+| **Scope creep** | Medium | Medium | Clear scope, change control process |
+| **Resource unavailability** | Medium | High | Buffer in schedule, backup resources |
+| **Stakeholder misalignment** | Low | High | Regular communication, demonstrate progress |
+
+### 4.3 Compliance Risks
+
+| Risk | Probability | Impact | Mitigation |
+|------|-------------|--------|------------|
+| **Regulatory non-compliance** | Low | Critical | Compliance review at each phase, external audit |
+| **Audit findings** | Medium | High | Implement controls early, regular internal audits |
+| **Data privacy violations** | Low | Critical | Encrypt everything, access controls, GDPR compliance |
+
+### 4.4 Business Risks
+
+| Risk | Probability | Impact | Mitigation |
+|------|-------------|--------|------------|
+| **Service disruption** | Low | Critical | Gradual rollout, rollback procedures, extensive testing |
+| **Budget overrun** | Medium | Medium | Detailed budgeting, contingency fund (20%) |
+| **Timeline slippage** | Medium | Medium | Realistic timeline, buffer in schedule, agile approach |
+| **Benefit realization delay** | Medium | Low | Quick wins, measure metrics, communicate successes |
+
+---
+
+## 5. Resource Requirements
+
+### 5.1 Team Allocation
+
+**Full-time (for 6 months):**
+- Project Manager: 1 FTE
+- DevOps Engineers: 2 FTE
+- Infrastructure Engineer: 1 FTE
+
+**Part-time:**
+- Security Architect: 0.5 FTE (more в certain phases)
+- Network Engineer: 0.5 FTE (Week 1-3, Week 11-14)
+- DBA: 0.25 FTE (database setups)
+- Compliance Officer: 0.25 FTE (reviews)
+
+**As-needed:**
+- Development team leads (training, migration)
+- Application teams (migration weeks)
+- External consultants (penetration testing)
+
+**Total Person-Months:** ~30 PM
+
+### 5.2 External Resources
+
+**Consultants:**
+- Penetration testing vendor: 1 week, $15k
+- Training partner (optional): $10k
+
+**Contractors (optional):**
+- Additional DevOps help: 2-3 months, $60k
+
+### 5.3 Training Time
+
+**Team members:**
+- 10 days formal training
+- 5 days hands-on practice
+- Ongoing learning (20% time)
+
+**Total training cost (opportunity cost):**
+- 20 people * 15 days * $500/day = $150k
+
+---
+
+## 6. Budget and ROI
+
+### 6.1 Implementation Costs
+
+**Capital Expenditure (CapEx):**
+
+| Category | Cost | Notes |
+|----------|------|-------|
+| **Servers** | $100,000 | 27 servers для production + dev |
+| **Storage** | $40,000 | SSD, HDD, NAS |
+| **Network Equipment** | $50,000 | Switches, firewall, VPN |
+| **GPU (Ollama)** | $15,000 | NVIDIA GPUs для AI |
+| **Backup Systems** | $10,000 | Backup appliance |
+| **Contingency (20%)** | $43,000 | Unexpected expenses |
+| **Total CapEx** | **$258,000** | |
+
+**Operational Expenditure (OpEx - Year 1):**
+
+| Category | Cost | Notes |
+|----------|------|-------|
+| **Software Licenses** | $20,000 | Portainer, monitoring tools |
+| **Training** | $25,000 | External training, materials |
+| **Consulting** | $25,000 | Penetration testing, consultants |
+| **Internal Resources** | $180,000 | 30 PM * $6k/PM |
+| **Misc** | $10,000 | Travel, documentation, etc. |
+| **Total OpEx (Year 1)** | **$260,000** | |
+
+**Total Implementation Cost:** $518,000
+
+### 6.2 Ongoing Costs (Annual)
+
+| Category | Annual Cost |
+|----------|-------------|
+| Software licenses | $20,000 |
+| Maintenance & support | $30,000 |
+| Training (ongoing) | $10,000 |
+| Infrastructure costs (power, cooling) | $15,000 |
+| **Total Ongoing** | **$75,000/year** |
+
+### 6.3 Expected Benefits (Annual)
+
+**Quantifiable Benefits:**
+
+| Benefit | Annual Savings | Calculation |
+|---------|----------------|-------------|
+| **Reduced Downtime** | $200,000 | Fewer incidents, faster recovery |
+| **Team Productivity** | $150,000 | 40% time savings on deployment tasks |
+| **Faster Time to Market** | $100,000 | Competitive advantage, revenue |
+| **Reduced Infrastructure** | $30,000 | Better utilization, fewer servers needed |
+| **Total Annual Benefits** | **$480,000** | |
+
+**Intangible Benefits:**
+- Improved security posture
+- Better compliance (avoid penalties)
+- Higher team morale
+- Attract/retain talent (modern stack)
+- Competitive advantage
+
+### 6.4 ROI Calculation
+
+```
+Total Investment: $518,000 (Year 0)
+Annual Benefit: $480,000
+Annual Cost: $75,000
+Net Annual Benefit: $405,000
+
+ROI Timeline:
+- Year 0: -$518,000
+- Year 1: -$518,000 + $405,000 = -$113,000
+- Year 2: -$113,000 + $405,000 = +$292,000
+- Year 3: +$697,000
+- Year 4: +$1,102,000
+- Year 5: +$1,507,000
+
+Payback Period: ~15 months
+5-Year ROI: 191%
+```
+
+**Sensitivity Analysis:**
+
+**Conservative (70% benefits):**
+- Net benefit: $284k/year
+- Payback: 22 months
+
+**Aggressive (130% benefits):**
+- Net benefit: $527k/year
+- Payback: 12 months
+
+---
+
+## 7. Success Metrics
+
+### 7.1 DORA Metrics (Key Performance Indicators)
+
+**Deployment Frequency:**
+- Baseline: 1-2 deployments/month
+- Target Year 1: 5 deployments/week
+- Target Year 2: 10+ deployments/day
+
+**Lead Time for Changes:**
+- Baseline: 2-4 weeks
+- Target Year 1: 1 day
+- Target Year 2: <4 hours
+
+**Mean Time to Recovery (MTTR):**
+- Baseline: 2-4 hours
+- Target Year 1: 30 minutes
+- Target Year 2: <15 minutes
+
+**Change Failure Rate:**
+- Baseline: 20-30%
+- Target Year 1: 10%
+- Target Year 2: <5%
+
+### 7.2 Business Metrics
+
+**Cost Savings:**
+- Infrastructure utilization improvement: +30%
+- Operational cost reduction: -$200k/year
+- Productivity improvement: +40% for DevOps team
+
+**Quality Metrics:**
+- Incidents in production: -60%
+- Mean time between failures: +200%
+- Customer satisfaction: +20%
+
+**Compliance Metrics:**
+- Audit findings: -80%
+- Compliance report generation time: -90%
+- Audit trail completeness: 100%
+
+### 7.3 Team Metrics
+
+**Adoption:**
+- Applications migrated to GitOps: Target 80% within 6 months
+- Active users: 100% of DevOps, 80% of developers
+- AI assistant usage: 50+ queries/week
+
+**Satisfaction:**
+- Team satisfaction survey: Target >4.5/5
+- Would recommend to colleague: Target >90%
+- Reduction в deployment stress: Target >50%
+
+---
+
+## 8. Communication Plan
+
+### 8.1 Stakeholder Communication
+
+**Executive Leadership:**
+- **Frequency:** Monthly
+- **Format:** Executive dashboard, brief report
+- **Content:** Progress, budget, risks, key decisions
+- **Owner:** Project Manager
+
+**Project Steering Committee:**
+- **Frequency:** Bi-weekly
+- **Format:** Steering committee meeting
+- **Content:** Detailed progress, risks, decisions needed
+- **Owner:** Project Manager
+
+**All Employees:**
+- **Frequency:** Monthly
+- **Format:** Company-wide email, demo sessions
+- **Content:** Project overview, benefits, what's coming
+- **Owner:** Project Manager + Comms team
+
+### 8.2 Team Communication
+
+**Project Team:**
+- **Daily standup:** 15 min, progress & blockers
+- **Weekly planning:** 1 hour, next week's work
+- **Retrospective:** Bi-weekly, lessons learned
+
+**Development Teams:**
+- **Migration briefings:** Before each batch migration
+- **Office hours:** Weekly Q&A sessions
+- **Slack channel:** Real-time support
+
+**Operations Team:**
+- **Operational readiness:** Weekly meetings during rollout
+- **Handover sessions:** Detailed knowledge transfer
+- **Run книги:** Comprehensive documentation
+
+### 8.3 Change Management
+
+**Communication Themes:**
+- Why are we doing this? (Benefits)
+- What does it mean for me? (Impact)
+- When will it happen? (Timeline)
+- How can I prepare? (Training)
+- Who can I ask? (Support)
+
+**Resistance Management:**
+- Listen к concerns
+- Address FUD (Fear, Uncertainty, Doubt)
+- Show early wins
+- Provide support
+- Celebrate successes
+
+---
+
+## 9. Go/No-Go Decision Points
+
+### 9.1 Milestone Gates
+
+**Gate 1: Development Environment Complete (Week 5)**
+
+**Go Criteria:**
+- All services operational
+- Integration tests passing
+- Team trained
+- Security review passed
+
+**No-Go Actions:**
+- Extend dev environment phase
+- Address critical issues
+- Re-plan production timeline
+
+**Gate 2: Production Environment Ready (Week 16)**
+
+**Go Criteria:**
+- Production environment operational
+- HA configured and tested
+- Security audit passed
+- Compliance sign-off received
+- Disaster recovery tested
+
+**No-Go Actions:**
+- Address critical security findings
+- Complete remaining configuration
+- Delay pilot migration
+
+**Gate 3: Pilot Success (Week 18)**
+
+**Go Criteria:**
+- Pilot applications successfully migrated
+- No critical incidents
+- Team comfortable with process
+- Positive feedback
+
+**No-Go Actions:**
+- Refine migration process
+- Additional training
+- Delay gradual migration
+
+**Gate 4: Full Rollout (Week 22)**
+
+**Go Criteria:**
+- Majority of apps migrated
+- Metrics showing improvement
+- Teams satisfied
+- Stable operations
+
+**No-Go Actions:**
+- Slow down migration pace
+- Address outstanding issues
+- Extended stabilization period
+
+---
+
+## 10. Post-Implementation
+
+### 10.1 Handover to Operations
+
+**Knowledge Transfer:**
+- Comprehensive runbooks
+- Architecture walkthrough
+- Troubleshooting guide
+- Escalation procedures
+
+**Operational Ownership:**
+- SRE team takes ownership
+- On-call rotation established
+- Incident management process
+- Continuous improvement backlog
+
+### 10.2 Continuous Improvement
+
+**Regular Activities:**
+- Monthly metrics review
+- Quarterly retrospectives
+- Annual architecture review
+- Ongoing optimization
+
+**Areas для Improvement:**
+- Performance tuning
+- Cost optimization
+- Security hardening
+- Feature enhancements
+- Team skill development
+
+### 10.3 Project Closure
+
+**Final Activities:**
+- Post-implementation review
+- Lessons learned documentation
+- Final cost accounting
+- Benefits realization tracking setup
+- Team recognition
+- Knowledge transfer complete
+- Project documentation archived
+
+**Success Celebration:**
+- Team dinner
+- Recognition awards
+- Company-wide announcement
+- Case study creation (internal)
+
+---
+
+**Final Approval:**
+
+| Role | Name | Signature | Date |
+|------|------|-----------|------|
+| Project Sponsor | _______________ | _______________ | _____ |
+| CTO | _______________ | _______________ | _____ |
+| CISO | _______________ | _______________ | _____ |
+| CFO | _______________ | _______________ | _____ |
+| Compliance Officer | _______________ | _______________ | _____ |